NAVIGARE
← Module 4 · Movement and nutrition

Soy, supplements and diet claims

Read 7 of 83 min readNo sign up needed

Let's talk about the claims you see online. Soy. Supplements. Special diets. What actually stands up?

The soy trial everyone quotes

In 2023, a trial called WAVS put postmenopausal women with frequent hot flushes on a low fat vegan diet with half a cup of cooked soybeans a day. After twelve weeks, they reported their moderate to severe hot flushes dropped by eighty eight percent.

That's a huge number. But there are big caveats. It was small, just eighty four women. The women knew which group they were in, and placebo effects in hot flush studies can be very large. It changed several things at once, and many women also lost weight. And it was funded by an organisation that promotes plant based diets. That doesn't make it wrong, but it does need repeating by independent researchers before anyone treats it as settled.

Why soy works for some women and not others

When some people eat soy, their gut bacteria turn it into a compound called equol. A review of trials found equol reduced hot flushes. But only about a third to a half of people have the gut bacteria to make it, and it varies between populations. So if soy has worked for your friend and not for you, that may be why.

If you want to try, add a portion of soy foods a day, like edamame, tofu or soya milk, for about twelve weeks and see.

The Mediterranean pattern

This is where the evidence is most consistent. Eating more vegetables, fruit, wholegrains, beans, nuts and olive oil, and fewer sugary and processed foods, is linked to better heart health, and in some studies fewer hot flushes. It's mostly observational evidence, but it all points the same way.

Supplements

The British Menopause Society says the only supplement recommended for all women at this stage is vitamin D. Everything else should only be taken if there's a clinical need, like iron if you're actually low.

Supplements marketed for menopause aren't regulated the way medicines are, and good trial evidence is mostly missing. If any of them worked as well as the adverts say, they'd be in the guidelines.

Fasting and keto

These haven't been properly studied in women going through perimenopause. Some people find time restricted eating suits them, and that's fine. But there's no evidence it's special for this stage.

The summary

No miracle food. No banned foods. A varied, mostly plant rich diet with enough protein, plus vitamin D. And be sceptical of anyone selling you a fix.

Sources

  1. Barnard ND et al. A dietary intervention for vasomotor symptoms of menopause. Menopause. 2023.
  2. Daily JW et al. Equol decreases hot flashes in postmenopausal women. J Med Food. 2019.
  3. British Menopause Society. Nutrition and weight gain. June 2023.
  4. Herber Gast GC, Mishra GD. Am J Clin Nutr. 2013.
Education, not medical advice. Written by a scientist, not a doctor. Nothing here is personalised to you or replaces your GP. If something is worrying you, please book an appointment.